Holiday · Home Management · Meal Plans · Recipes

Thanksgiving Meal and Holiday Plan

Home Well Managed Blog's Thanksgiving Meal PlanBecause I run a blog that, for the time being, is mostly about food I decided this year a holiday where massive amounts of food is prepared and consumed, deserves its very own post.  Aside from providing very specific meal plans for this glorious holiday, I have also included traditions, my own detailed timeline to get all the prep and cooking done in time, and a comprehensive shopping list.  Here it goes!


Whatever Dinner

We started this last year after I read about it in my Six Sister’s cookbook.  The day before Thanksgiving tends to be just as hectic as the holiday itself.  I get all the pies done that day as well as last minute grocery shopping and all the prep that I can possibly do beforehand.  By the end of the day when dinner time rolls around the very last thing I want to do is cook more food!  The Six Sisters cookbook explained that they were given $5 each to go buy whatever they wanted in the grocery store. Everyone combined their purchases and it made for a very unconventional, but I am sure a memorable, dinner.  Last year instead of browsing the grocery store, Trevor and I hit up three different fast food drive-thrus and each chose one item from their dollar menu.    Awesome tradition, enough said.

Turkey Bowl

Whether his family puts on an early morning touch football game or it is organized by members of our church this is an event that Trevor looks forward to every year.  This year we are far from family and in a new area so Trevor might just have to organize one himself.

Pie for Dinner

The title says it all.  I think part of the reason my mom always made so many pies is so we could eat them for days after.  Our Thanksgiving dinner happens around lunch time so later that day, when we are longer stuffed to the max and can tighten our belts again, we go grab the pies and dig in.  My mom was also fine with pumpkin or egg nog pie for breakfast.  I always looked forward to pie for breakfast the next day.

Black Friday Shopping

This one really makes me miss being close to family and childhood friends.  I am fully aware I can do all my black Friday shopping online but where is the fun in that?  As soon as my parents let me stay out that late, a friend and I would leave the house around 9:00, stop to buy hot chocolate, and hit up all the deals we had researched and planned for.  Then you also end up coming home with more than you had planned for because some deals you just cannot pass up!  Yes you stand in crazy long lines, yes it’s cold, and yes you get home really late.  Sometimes making memories is just worth the sacrifice. Also, I  get the large majority of all my Christmas shopping done in one night.  Last year we were on our own for the holiday too so I just went by myself and Trevor stayed with the baby.  It definitely was not as fun, so hopefully I can find another person crazy like me for that adventure this year.

What are your favorite Thanksgiving traditions?  Share below to give us ideas!

Home Well Managed Blog's Thanksgiving Meal Plans

Meal Plans


Trevor has requested French toast, so we will use this Thick and Rich Best Ever French Toast recipe and I will try it with my Udi’s gluten free bread. We will top ours with bananas and peanut butter and lots of syrup on Trevor’s end.


*Cheese Ball

served with various crackers, and celery

*Stuffed Mushrooms


2 packages of whole mushrooms

8 oz cream cheese

1 package Ground Italian Sausage (jimmy dean)

1/2 tsp oregano

1/4 tsp ground red pepper (optional)

1/2 pepper

1/2 tsp garlic salt

1/2 cup parmesan cheese

1 egg

Stem and core mushrooms.Crease a cookie sheet and set oven for 350 degrees.  Cook sausage with spices and then drain.  mix in softened cream cheese with an egg and Parmesan.  Spoon heaping amounts into each mushroom and bake for 20 minutes.  Note: you may need to take mushrooms out half way through and soak up some of the liquid in the pan.



I am cheating – buying one already cooked from Costco that I just have to warm. I feel no guilt from this, roasting a turkey intimidates me for some reason and I care more about the sides anway.

*World’s Best Mashed Potatoes w/ Turkey Gravy


This will also be store bought from a box.  My mom always used a box and it is always a hit.

Best Green Bean Casserole

I found gluten free fried onions so I am giving this dish a go this year.  Substitute this recipe for the cream of mushroom soup recipe below

Gluten Free Cream of Mushroom Soup

In a microwave safe bowl, combine the following ingredients and microwave for 2 minutes or until thickened to desired consistency. Taste first, I usually add more bouillon and salt)

1 1/4 c milk       2 tbsp cornstarch

1/4 tsp thyme   4 oz mushrooms chopped fine

1/4 tsp garlic     1 tsp chicken bouillon

1/2 tsp salt

*Sweet Potato Casserole

Gluten free note: I substitute an all purpose gf flour and add cinnamon to the crumb topping.

French Bread Rolls

Obviously these are not gluten free, but I am not perfect and sometimes I cheat because…Thanksgiving.

Darby’s French Bread

Preheat oven to 400 degrees

2 C warm water

1 Tbsp yeast

1 1/2 tsp salt

2 tbsp sugar(I use brown)

2 tbsp oil

about 3 1/2-4 cups flour-until not sticky

Knead at least 10 minutes and let raise 1/2 hour.  Form into roll and put in the pan with some space in between. Let raise for 10-15 minutes.  Bake 10 minutes or until tops are golden.


I use the Best Gluten Free Pie Crust (pictured above) and my family cannot even tell the difference.  I also use the Truvia stevia baking blend in my pies instead of sugar.  We cannot tell the difference because the blend bakes the same and doesn’t have that weird sugar substitute aftertaste.

*Holiday Egg Nog Custard

*Banana Cream Pie

I use cornstarch instead of flour

*Chocolate Pudding Pie w/ Meringue


My favorite recipe and the one my mom has always used is one on the back of the Libby’s can of pumpkin.

Home Well Managed Blog's Thanksgiving Meal Plan

Cooking and Prep Timeline

Day Before

  • Organize Fridge/ Make Space
  •        Make Cheeseball
  •        Bake Pies
  •        Clean the house
  •        Do all dishes and empty sink night before

Day Of

  •          8:30 am – put turkey into crockpot to warm on low, breakfast
  •         10:00 am – Prep stuffed mushrooms and Prep Sweet Potato Casserole
  •         11:00 am – Set table, serve appetizers, make stuffing/put in microwave to warm
  •         12:00 pm – Prep rolls, mushrooms in the oven, chop potatoes
  •         12:20 pm – Sweet potatoes in the oven, green beans in oven,  boil potatoes
  •         12:45 pm – Make mashed potatoes and gravy, green beans in oven to toast onion
  •        12:50  pm –  Slice Turkey, rolls in the oven,
  •         1:00 pm –    EAT ALL THE FOOD

Stuffed Mushrooms – 350 degrees for 20 mins

Sweet Potato Casserole – 350 degrees for 30 mins

Green Bean Casserole – 350 degrees for 30 mins

Rolls- 400 degrees for 10 mins

Shopping List

  • GF bread
  • eggs – 2 dozen
  • milk
  • half and half
  • bananas
  • peanut butter
  • syrup
  • cream cheese x4
  • mayonnaise
  • grated parmesan cheese
  • shredded cheddar cheese
  •  chopped green onions
  • worcestershire sauce
  • garlic powder
  • sliced almonds
  • crackers
  • garlic salt
  • pepper
  • 1 package Ground Italian Sausage (jimmy dean)
  • 2 packages of whole mushrooms
  • turkey gravy
  • 5lb bag of potatoes
  • butter
  • seasoning salt
  • box of stuffing
  • celery
  • chicken broth
  • GF fried onions
  • canned green beans x2
  • cornstarch
  • canned mushrooms
  • pecans
  • sweet potatoes x3
  • truvia sugar baking blend
  • truvia brown sugar blend
  • vanilla
  • all purpose GF flour
  • flour
  • canola oil
  • salt
  • yeast
  • egg nog
  • nutmeg
  • pie tins x4
  • bananas x3
  • cool whip
  • cream of tarter
  • cocoa powder
  • Libby’s can of pumpkin
  • canned milk
  • cinnamon
  • sparkling cider x2
  • canned cranberry sauce
  • turkey


    There you have it!  I hope your holiday is full of family, loads of pie and even more gratitude for all the blessings in our lives.







10 thoughts on “Thanksgiving Meal and Holiday Plan

  1. Holy Hannah!! You’re a rockstar!! I wish I could make a timeline for the day of, it just is pure chaos around my house until we finally sit down and eat…whenever everything happens to get done, lol.
    Also, in case you’re ever curious, homemade stuffing is super easy, and not a lot of ingredients. One of my favorite memories of Thanksgiving is when my mom finally let me cut the loaves of bread for the stuffing, I wasn’t allowed in the kitchen though, so I got to sit at the dinner table, watch the parade, and cut 6-8 loaves of bread!!
    I might be on my own for Black Friday this year too. There’s a deal on a baby monitor at Target that I just cannot pass up. Unfortunately, it’s a doorbuster, and they open at like 5 or 6, so it’s going to be an early Thanksgiving for us!! Sure do miss my crazy Black Friday partner!!


  2. One of my favorite traditions is staying up late to watch a Christmas movie to set the season into motion. And yes to all the “in real shopping” that makes for way more fun! xo, Jessica


  3. I so love the whatever dinner idea! And I’m totally into Black Friday too! It’s just such a fun night & bonding with whatever friends & family you go with.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s